top of page

Upcoming ICJ Ruling and Its Dangerous Negative Consequences

12 hours ago
4 min read

Kyaw Zan, Opinion, November 18, 2026

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, State Counsellor of Myanmar, defended her country at the court (photocrd)
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, State Counsellor of Myanmar, defended her country at the court (photocrd)

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is expected to announce its ruling on November 19 in the genocide case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar over the treatment of the Muslims in Arakan "Rohingya". The upcoming decision is likely to create further political divisions within Myanmar, a country already suffering from deep internal conflict and political instability.


Although the majority of the population may reject the military junta because of its atrocities, crimes and systematic suppression, the ICJ case presents a more complicated political challenge. Supporting justice and accountability for military crimes does not necessarily mean accepting every political narrative or historical claim associated with the case. This distinction is particularly important for the people of Arakan, whose history, security and political interests must not be overlooked.


The first major concern is how the military junta may exploit the ICJ ruling for its own political survival. Despite being responsible for widespread atrocities against civilians, the military could attempt to reject any ruling that supports The Gambia's arguments, particularly a finding that Myanmar committed genocide or failed to prevent it. More importantly, the junta may use the ruling to mobilize ultra-nationalist and religious groups, presenting itself as the defender of national sovereignty, religion and the country's population.


Such a strategy would allow the military to shift public attention away from its ongoing crimes and political failures. It could also create a dangerous political environment in which legitimate demands for justice are portrayed as attacks on the country, its people or their religious identity. In this way, the military could turn an international accountability process into another instrument for strengthening its domestic political position.


The National Unity Government (NUG), meanwhile, could face an equally difficult political dilemma. If it supports a ruling in favour of The Gambia, it may appear to have departed from the previous position of the National League for Democracy (NLD), under which Daw Aung San Suu Kyi personally defended Myanmar at the ICJ. However, rejecting such a ruling could undermine the NUG's commitment to human rights, justice and accountability, principles that form an important part of its political struggle against military rule.


This dilemma demonstrates how the ICJ case could become a political test for opposition forces. Nevertheless, the pursuit of justice should not be reduced to choosing between political positions inherited from the past. The more important question is whether all victims of military crimes, regardless of their ethnicity or religion, can receive justice and recognition.


For anti-junta forces that genuinely seek justice and accountability, the priority should be to support measures that directly weaken the military's capacity to continue its war and commit further atrocities. This includes sanctions targeting military imports and the junta's war economy.


At the same time, international accountability mechanisms should be welcomed because they can expose the crimes committed by the military against all indigenous ethnic communities, not only Muslim communities. Justice cannot be selective, and accountability should not depend on the identity of the victims. The suffering of one community must not be used to deny or overshadow the suffering of another.


Equally important, the upcoming ICJ ruling must not have the unintended consequence of strengthening one-sided political narratives surrounding the controversial identity of "Rohingya" or legitimizing historical and population claims that remain disputed by other communities in Arakan. A legal ruling on allegations of genocide should not automatically be interpreted as international recognition of every historical, ethnic or political claim associated with this identity.


Such an interpretation could deepen existing tensions and create serious concerns among other ethnic and religious communities in Arakan, including Rakhine, Hindu, Mro and other indigenous groups. Their historical identity, collective rights and continued existence must not be undermined or placed at risk through the political interpretation of an international court ruling. Justice for one community should never become a means of weakening the rights, history and security of others.


Another serious concern is how extremist groups within the Muslim community, particularly ARSA and other armed organizations, might exploit the ruling for their own political and ideological purposes. They could portray an ICJ decision in favour of The Gambia as international endorsement of their political demands or as evidence that they enjoy protection from international institutions.


Such a misleading interpretation could encourage some extremist elements to believe that they can commit further violence against other communities without facing consequences. However, an ICJ ruling on state responsibility cannot grant any armed group permission to commit crimes, nor does it provide immunity for attacks against civilians. The international community must clearly communicate this distinction and ensure that all armed groups remain accountable for their actions.


The international community must also remain alert to the possible activities of extremist groups in northern Arakan. The actions of ARSA in August 2017, following the Kofi Annan Commission's report, demonstrated how extremist violence can destroy opportunities for peace and stability. Similar threats must not be ignored or allowed to develop under the cover of international political developments.


Ultimately, justice for the Rohingya and accountability for the Myanmar military should not come at the expense of justice for other communities. The ICJ process must not be exploited by the junta, extremist organizations or political actors to advance narrow interests. A sustainable solution requires recognition of all victims, respect for historical realities, protection of every community's rights and equal accountability for crimes committed by all perpetrators. Without these principles, the upcoming ruling could deepen existing divisions rather than contribute to justice, reconciliation and lasting stability.

Member Login

FOLLOW US

  • Telegram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube

© 2024 Global Arakan Network (GAN). All Right Reserved

bottom of page